Law Clerk Addict's Blog



Two days ago we reported that President Barack Obama's decision to delegate the selection of a nominee to replace disgraced former judge Samuel Kent (S.D. Tex.) to Congressional Democrats rather than Texas's two Republican home-state Senators set the stage for a potential conflict between President Obama and Senators Kay Bailey Hutchinson and John Cornyn that, if taken to its natural conclusion, could significantly delay confirmation of nominees to these Texas seats.


Now, it appears that delay will be inevitable, with Texas Senate Republicans and Texas Congressional Democrats conducting parallel nominee screening processes to determine a potential replacement for Chief Judge Hayden Head (S.D. Tex.), who intends to assume senior status in November. Although it is true that Republicans are a minority in the Senate, there are many instances in which home-state minority senators have been able to successfully obstruct district judge nominees that lack their approval. See, e.g., Carl Levin's (D-MI) obstruction of President George W. Bush's nominees to the Western District of Michigan for more than six years until Bush agreed to nominate some Democrats to the seats.


On a related note, those interested in biographical information about potential nominees to replace Chief Judge Head may find this article useful.




Comments for Judicial Nomination Confusion in Texas Continues


Leave a Comment Visitor Comments
Fill out this form to add a new comment.
Author:
Date: 2012-02-09 01:45:59
Subject:
Comment:

NOTE: Our spam blocker automatically blocks all posts attempting to link to other websites. If you have tried to post something and it did not show up, please repost it without the hyperlink.

 Senate Judiciary

Jul 12, 2009, 8:21 PM 

#1

In this regard, I think it's important to note the generally adopted Senate Judiciary policy, continued by Senator Leahy, of seeking approval from the home state senators before allowing a judicial nominee to go to the committee in the first instance. I'm guessing Obama's nominee, if not approved by Hutchinson and Cornyn, will never make it to the committee, let alone the full senate.


 – Anonymous (Unregistered)

 
 

 2005

Jun 1, 2011, 8:14 PM 

#2

I'm out of league here. Too much brain power on dsipaly!


 – Lavigne (Unregistered)